The question that many ask when deciding to buy whey protein is:
“Should I buy an isolated or concentrated whey?!”
We advise you to take a look at our article Isolated vs Concentrated Whey, is the isolated one worth it?.
However, if you are undecided between concentrated Impact Whey and isolated Impact Whey, this is the right article!
Find out the differences between the brand's concentrated Impact Whey and the brand's isolated Impact Whey Myprotein.
The versions analyzed are unflavored.
Presentation
Both the concentrated Impact Whey and the isolated version are available in 3 different sizes.
In the case of concentrate, it is available in 1kg, 2.5kg and 5kg.
In the isolated version, we have Impact Whey in 1kg, 2.5kg and 4kg.
This refers to the unflavored version, flavored versions may vary.
Nutritional value
We have already had the opportunity to analyze the Impact Whey concentrate previously and confirm that it is an excellent protein. Let's now put it side by side with the isolated version and see what the differences are in nutritional terms between the two.
Impact Whey/25g | Impact Isolated/25g | |
Calories | 98.3 Kcal | 92.5 Kcal |
Protein | 20.5g | 23g |
Carbohydrates | 1.5g | 0.17g |
Fat | 1.7g | 0.25g |
Impact Whey/100g | Impact Isolated/100g | |
Calories | 393.2 Kcal | 370 Kcal |
Protein | 82g | 92g |
Carbohydrates | 6g | 0.68g |
Fat | 6.8g | 1g |
As expected, the isolated version is superior to the concentrated version, not only having 10g more protein per 100 grams of product, but also presenting extremely low carbohydrate and fat values.
Impact Whey concentrate has a protein concentration of 82%, while the isolated version has 92% of protein!
In addition to these general values, it is also important to analyze the aminogram of each supplement.
Simply put, we have put together a comparative table below between these proteins in terms of BCAA's, the most important amino acids for building muscle.
Impact Whey | Impact Isolated | |
Total Protein/100g | 82g | 92g |
BCAA's/dose | 4.7g | 5.32g |
BCAA's/100g | 18.77g | 21.297g |
While the concentrate has 18.7g of BCAA's for every 100g of product, the isolated version has 21.29g, a reasonable and perfectly normal difference, as we have a higher concentration of 10% protein in the isolated one.
Price
Regarding which protein is the best in terms of quality, we have no doubt that it is the isolated version, however, the price remains to be analyzed and this is where doubts arise regarding which one is the best bet.
Impact Whey concentrate
Impact Whey | 1kg | 2.5kg | 5kg |
Doses | 40 | 100 | 200 |
Cost per dose | 0.37? | 0.31 ? | 0.27 ? |
Total cost | 14.89? | 30.89? | 54.89? |
Impact Whey Isolate
Impact Isolated | 1kg | 2.5kg | 4kg |
Doses | 40 | 100 | 160 |
Cost per dose | 0.57 ? | 0.48? | 0.45? |
Total cost | 22.89? | 48.89? | 71.99? |
Looking at the table, we can see that the price difference is significant, and concentrated Whey has a clear advantage here, making it an excellent protein in terms of price/quality.
Where to buy?
You can find the concentrated version here and the isolated version here.
Conclusion
A Impact Whey Isolate It is clearly the best protein, winning in all categories when it comes to quality, however, this quality comes at a price.
A Impact Whey concentrate It is also an excellent protein, with a more affordable price.
We can say that the concentrate is the winner when it comes to price/quality, while the isolate clearly takes the trophy for best protein, as expected.
If you have a limited budget, the concentrated version is the best option and you will undoubtedly be well served.
If money is not a problem, the isolated version is one of the best whey's on the market, and has a protein content of 93%, all with virtually no carbohydrates and fat.
You can find both supplements here.
Pass by this link and get an even better price on these supplements with Myprotein codes!
Goodnight!
What is the recommended dose to take after training? 25g or 100g of isolated protein?
Thanks!
25/30g is usually enough ;)
25/30g is the measure of the scoop that should be inside, right?
Yes, the scoop of both Myprotein concentrate and isolate is 25g.
OK thank you!
Goodnight! Over the last few months I have always ordered natural impact whey isolate from my protein, and the nutritional values matched everything correctly and I liked the results! This week I ordered an isolate but with white chocolate, as the flavor is on discount! I received it today, and I looked at the nutritional values and there were, per 25g, 14g of carbohydrates of which 14g were sugar! How is this possible in an isolated protein?
Thanks!
It's most likely a printing problem and the comma is missing, but nothing like contacting Myprotein to confirm :)